Secretive American Stocks Of Soviet Air Defense Systems Are Headed To Ukraine: Report
The US has captured, snatched, or otherwise acquired various Russian-made air defense systems over the years, and now they could fight in Ukraine.
JOSEPH TREVITHICK View Joseph Trevithick's Articles
The U.S. government is
sending Soviet-era air defense systems in its possession to Ukraine, according
to a report from The Wall Street Journal. These
systems will reportedly come from stocks of foreign materiel that elements of
the U.S. military and Intelligence Community have obtained in various ways over the years for intelligence analysis and training purposes. The possibility that
these so-called foreign materiel exploitation, or FME,
programs could offer a useful source of additional air defense capabilities
that Ukraine badly needs is exactly what that The War Zone laid out just recently.
It's not entirely clear
from The Wall Street Journal's story,
which was published earlier today, which entity or entities
within the U.S. government is managing this effort. The story indicates that an
arm of the U.S. military, broadly, is managing this military assistance
project, but says that Pentagon declined to comment one way or the other.
The Journal's piece did
say that the U.S. government has already shipped a number of systems to Ukraine
that had been in storage at the U.S. Army's Redstone
Arsenal in Huntsville, Alabama. U.S. Air Force C-17 Globemaster III cargo planes reportedly
picked them up at an unspecified airfield in the Huntsville area. The story
notes that Redstone is home to the Army's Aviation and
Missile Command (AMCOM), but it also hosts the Defense
Intelligence Agency's (DIA) Missile
and Space Intelligence Center (MSIC), which has an
FME role. DIA serves as the focal point for the Department of Defense's entire
FME enterprise, as well.
The U.S. military has
been very active in delivering and otherwise facilitating the shipment of
military aid to Ukraine, even before Russia launched its invasion. This
includes various air defense systems, especially different types of shoulder-fired surface-to-air missiles, also known
as man-portable air-defense systems (MANPADS). In addition, American officials
have made clear that there is a heavy emphasis on sending weapons and equipment
that Ukrainian forces are already familiar with, an idea The War Zone had earlier explained the merits of. The core idea behind
that philosophy is that this will make it faster and easier for Ukraine's
military to actively put what it receives to use in combat. Ukraine's ground-based air defenses have
been essential in preventing Russian forces from gaining air superiority over the
country after more than three weeks of fighting.
Beyond all this, it's
still unclear what systems specifically may ultimately be transferred to
Ukraine. The SA-8 Gecko is the only specific
system that the Journal's sources
named as being among the planned deliveries to Ukrainian forces. The SA-8, also
known by the Russian nomenclature 9K33 Osa, is a wheeled short-range
surface-to-air missile system. DIA's MSIC is known to have at least one example
of this system in its inventory.
USAF
A US military-owned SA-8 Gecko.
USAF
An SA-8 Gecko belonging to the US Air Force's
547th Intelligence Squadron.
An anonymous source also
stressed to the Journal that an S-300 long-range
surface-to-air missile system, also referred to by NATO as the SA-10 Grumble,
which the U.S. government quietly acquired from Belarus in 1994, would remain
in the United States.
It's hard to say for sure
what other options there might be in the U.S. military's stockpile when it
comes to Soviet-era and/or Russian-made air defense systems that the Ukrainian
military has existing experience with. Much about the U.S. military's FME
ecosystem, which is one component of a larger one within the U.S. Intelligence
Community, is highly classified owing in no small part to the often covert or clandestine methods by which foreign
military systems are obtained.
UKRAINE NEEDS GROUND-BASED AIR
DEFENSES WAY MORE THAN MIGS. HERE ARE THE BEST OPTIONSBy Tyler
Rogoway and Thomas NewdickPosted in THE WAR ZONE
UKRAINIAN IL-76 AIRLIFTER THAT
WAS TRACKED ACROSS U.S. DELIVERED RADAR ASSET TO UTAH AIR BASEBy Joseph TrevithickPosted
in THE WAR ZONE
AIR FORCE RELEASES LIST OF
WHAT'S IN ITS FAMOUS 'PETTING ZOO' THREAT TRAINING FACILITYBy Brett
TingleyPosted in THE WAR ZONE
THE UNITED STATES SMUGGLED A
RUSSIAN-MADE PANTSIR AIR DEFENSE SYSTEM OUT OF LIBYA: REPORTBy Joseph
TrevithickPosted in THE WAR ZONE
NIGHT STALKER MH-47D CHINOOKS
ONCE SNATCHED A LIBYAN HIND GUNSHIP FROM CHADBy Joseph
TrevithickPosted in THE WAR ZONE
Still, it seems plausible,
if not probable that if the U.S. government has decided to dig into its FME
stocks to help Ukraine and that it will consider transferring relevant systems
from across the entire enterprise, not just from within DIA or the Army. The
U.S. Air Force alone is known to have additional examples of the SA-8, as well as other types
that are currently in Ukrainian service, like the SA-13 and the SA-15
Gauntlet. The latter two systems, also known by the
Russian nomenclature 9K35 Strela-10 and 9K332 Tor-M2E, are both tracked
short-range air defense systems.
USAF
An SA-15B Gauntlet arrives at the US Air Force's
Eielson Air Force Base in Alaska for an exercise in 2011.
The videos
below show members of the Air Force's 547th Intelligence
Squadron conducting familiarization training on a Soviet-era SA-13 Gopher
that belongs to the unit. This squadron operates the Threat Training
Facility at Nellis Air Force Base in Nevada, nicknamed
the "Petting Zoo," which
contains examples of various foreign systems.
These are just some
examples of the wide array of Soviet-era and/or Russian-made mobile air defense
systems that U.S. FME programs are known to possess. There are others that
could be of use to Ukrainian forces, too such as variants of the Buk series. You can read
more about the Buk's general capabilities, as well as the SA-8, SA-13, SA-15B,
and the S-300, in our recent feature on the best possible ways to bolster
Ukraine's air and missile defense capabilities here.
There are various types of MANPADS in the U.S.
military's stockpiles of foreign equipment that could potentially be
transferred to Ukraine, as well.
The CNN
segment from 2015 seen below includes a demonstration of a Soviet-era SA-7 Strela MANPADS
trainer at DIA's MSIC.
As was discussed in The War Zone's recent feature about Ukraine's air
and missile defense needs, there are certainly questions about the
functionality of these systems, including whether there are any stocks of
actual missiles to go with them, and the general utility of sending what could
be relatively small numbers of them to Ukraine. U.S. military training and
developmental activities that demand threat-representative systems could be
negatively impacted by these transfers, too.
At the same time, the
Ukrainian armed forces are in an all-hands-on-deck situation where
they can hardly afford to turn down military assistance of any kind, let alone
additional air defense capacity in the form of familiar systems that could be
put into action quickly. Some of the systems that the U.S. military might
transfer could have even originally come to the United States via the Ukrainian government. Ukraine has
been a huge source of FME assets in the past, from fighter jets to radar systems.
Even if the U.S. military has no missiles to send
along with some or all of these systems, the Ukrainians could use their own
stocks of missiles to make them operational or simply use them as sources of
spare parts to help keep other examples running.
For the U.S. government,
the FME stockpiles present the additional benefit of being entirely at
America's discretion to transfer to Ukraine. U.S. officials have been actively
working with other allies and partners to try to find more stocks of Soviet-era
and Russian-made air defense systems, among other things, that could go to
Ukraine. However, those third-party countries have often been wary of such deals for
political reasons or have had stipulations of their own that
could be complicated to meet.
ELLSWORTHSK
VIA WIKIMEDIA
The US government has been in discussions with
Slovakia about the potential transfer of its S-300 systems, components of which
are seen here, to Ukraine.
When it comes to the U.S.
military's own requirements for real-world threat systems, American officials
may believe that they can now effectively recreate many of them, especially
older types, through a combination of simulators and surrogates. In addition, Russia's
losses in Ukraine could eventually present a very real opportunity for the U.S.
military's FME enterprise to get its hands on much newer Russian air defense
systems, as well as other weapons and materiel of interest, if U.S. officials
haven't been arranging those kinds of transfers out of the country already.
With at least some transfers of Soviet-era and
Russian-made air defense systems from the U.S. military's FME programs already
reportedly in the process of being gifted to the Ukrainian military, it may not
be long before we start learning more about what is being provided and how is
it being employed. No matter what, Ukraine's armed forces remain in desperate
need of additional air defense capacity to help keep the skies above the
country contested.
Ingen kommentarer:
Legg inn en kommentar
Merk: Bare medlemmer av denne bloggen kan legge inn en kommentar.