Tom Young, Contributor
Author, veteran,
and airline pilot
Stolen Competence: Trump’s
Claim on Aviation Safety
01/03/2018 08:12
am ET
·
This week brought
great news about commercial aviation: 2017 was
the safest year in history. And Donald Trump wasted no time
claiming credit. He tweeted: “Since
taking office I have been very strict on Commercial Aviation.”
That’s hardly the
most hateful or harmful statement from this president. But to people in
aviation, it might be the dumbest. No chief executive gets involved with
day-to-day aviation enforcement; that’s the job of the Federal Aviation
Administration. And Trump
has not even named a permanent replacement for retiring FAA administrator
Michael Huerta.
Last year’s great
safety record stems, of course, from decades of hard work by professionals
toiling in anonymity. The genius of aeronautical engineers, the oversight of
regulators, the dedication of air traffic controllers, and the skill of air
crews all combined to bring about this achievement. Trump’s claim is a civilian
equivalent of stolen valor—when someone who never served puts on a uniform and
struts around a mall to collect admiring glances. Stolen competence, in this
case.
The idea that the
president saved aviation by being “very strict” is all the more absurd when you
know about the Aviation
Safety Reporting System. If anything, it’s lenient. If a pilot makes
an honest mistake that doesn’t cause an accident—for example, climbing to the
wrong altitude—he or she can fess up and fill out a report on what happened.
Having filed the report, the pilot can avoid penalties, and that way, we all
learn from each other’s mistakes. It’s a great system; I’ve used it myself, and
it’s one reason flying has become so safe.
In this era of
celebrity worship, perhaps we should take a moment to consider who really
should get the credit here. Above, engineers topped my list. They’ve invented
gizmos that can tell a pilot when something bad is about to happen—and provide
enough time to stop the bad thing from happening. The Traffic Collision Avoidance
System, or TCAS, will tell you to climb or descend to prevent a
mid-air. The Ground
Proximity Warning System, or GPWS, says: “Hey, dummy, don’t fly into
that mountain in front of you.”
Once inventors
create this wonderful stuff, regulators—yes, those black-suited bureaucrats of
the Deep State—determine how to employ the new technology. If a new invention
can save lives, someone has to make sure that invention actually gets used.
Regulators also set guidelines for training, aircraft maintenance, and rest
requirements.
And speaking of
government employees, let’s talk about another big reason for flight safety—air
traffic controllers. They coordinate what amounts to precision crowd-control in
the skies, and they’re more than mere mortals. Seriously. Their ability to
bring order to chaos should be considered a superpower. If we had our values
straight, there would be movies and comic books about air traffic Controllers.
Aircraft mechanics
also share the credit. In broiling summer heat and in this week’s bitter
freeze, they’re outside making sure your aircraft is ready to fly.
Then there are the
air crews, and more importantly, the people who train them. As you read
this—even if you read it in the middle of the night—there are pilots and
instructors in simulators and in briefing rooms. The instructors are passing on
lessons learned in a mentorship chain that goes all the way back to Orville and
Wilbur.
Aviation safety
brought a glimmer of good news about a year that will be more remembered for
political rancor, alternative facts, and rank hypocrisy. Perhaps we can look
forward to another safe year in flying, brought to you by old-fashioned values
that need to return to the forefront our national life: Competence. Expertise.
Honesty.
Ingen kommentarer:
Legg inn en kommentar
Merk: Bare medlemmer av denne bloggen kan legge inn en kommentar.